杨美君
回复 杨豪柔 :校园突击MaskedfigureswithmachinegunsmarchintothesecondaryschoolinKaratas,takethepupilshostage,andexecuteoneofthem.Theymakenodemands.Silentterroristheirmodusoperandi.Seeingasthearmywilltaketwodaystoarriveduetoasnowstorm,mathsteacherTazshidecidestoassemblehisownassaultteam:hisex-wife,thegymteacher,thecowardlyschoolprincipal,analcoholicnightwatchman,thevillageidiot,andanincompetentchiefofpolice.Whatfollowsisnotraditionalactionfilm,butathrillerwithsnatchesofcomedy,inwhichtheenemyisn’thiddenbehindmasks,butisinthemindsoftheliberators.Beforetheyact,theyhavetoovercometheirpersonaldemons.Comparisonstotheschoolhostage-takingsinBeslanandKazanareobvious,yetKaratas–themythicalvillagewheremuchofdirectorAdilkhanYerzhanov’sworkisset–couldbeanywhere.Itisuniversallyacknowledgedthatcrisesbringoutpeople'struenatures.
吕碧杰
回复 杨泓欣 :波特兰寻根环游记，一早醒来发现自己的波特兰消失了，典型的概念先行日式无厘头喜剧。可惜点子全用在创意上了，本应着重强调的“寻根之旅”却异常平庸，文本联系感太弱，拼凑感重，友情爱情亲情，意念不合抛弃朋友、前妻的幸福生活以及女儿的认出、和父亲一如即往的隔阂和母亲的爱…
